• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer
  • Home

You are here: Home / Spring 2021 / Spring 2021: Course/Section / Spring 2021: 414-01 / PSYC 414-01_Spring21_Group2

Importance of Parenting: Exploring Effects of Parenting Style on Identity Status, Risk Behaviors, and Self-Esteem in College Students

Lucy Bondje, Grace Gartman, Carmen Nichols,
& Emma Snyder

a Research Seminar Project supervised by Dr. Virginia Mackintosh (Spring 2021)

    Dr. Rettinger
    28 Apr 2021
    11:11am

    Your slides really look great. You have a flair for design.

    My biggest question has to do with cause and effect relationships between your variables. Do you think that self-esteem can affect parenting? As a parent, I imagine that I might treat my child differently based on their personality, which in turn would lead to different interactions and later behavior. Did you come across any research on this topic?

    Have there been any major changes in thinking about parenting style since Baumrind in the 60’s? Our culture has changed a lot since then and I wonder if the research has caught up?

    Reply
    Holly Schiffrin
    28 Apr 2021
    12:23pm

    I really liked the way that you presented the discussion comparing what the prior research had said to what you found in this study. It was very clear. One question, was the correlation between authoritative and risky sexual behavior positive or negative? The wording says positive, but there is a negative sign in front of the correlation. I wasn’t sure which was accurate. Assuming that it really was positive, why do you think you found the opposite of what prior research has found? Also, be careful about using causal language (e.g., “lead to”) when reviewing the results from correlational/descriptive studies. Stick with words like associated or related to in your paper.

    Reply
    Walker Chilton
    28 Apr 2021
    1:50pm

    I would also like to tag along on what Dr. Rettinger stated about the literature being fairly old. Do you think after conducting this study that some of the literature may not be as accurate as it once was? I know that parenting styles from that time period are much different than parenting styles currently. A lot of the parenting styles from then would not fit into the new norm of parenting now. I am sure everyone has heard their parents tell stories about how they were parented and most of their punishments would be very frowned upon now. So I was just wondering if literature from that time period would match up with your thoughts after conducting this study. The slides looked awesome!

    Reply
    Maggie Millar
    29 Apr 2021
    4:01pm

    Hey guys, I think you all did a great job on your research project! My research methods group also conducted a study on parenting styles, and we also used a modified version of the PAQ (a different version though)! We had a lot of similar limitations in our study, which could further support your claim of a poor reflective participant pool! Based on the literature and your results, why do you think that authoritative parenting styles were associated with more prescription drug abuse whereas permissive parenting styles were associated with more alcohol abuse? Great job, and I love your powerpoint slides!

    Reply
    Marie Bright
    29 Apr 2021
    10:53pm

    Hi all! I loved the theme of your slides. Did you find that the parents’ marital status had an effect on identity status, risk behaviors and self-esteem? Why do you think that the Authoritarian parenting style was negatively correlated? Is it because the participants realized and know that they would not want to be that type of parent in the future.

    Reply
    Kira Flinn
    2 May 2021
    6:36pm

    Hi everyone! This project was very well put together and thought out! One question that I had was, do you think that having a significant other or friends could have contributed to participants having high and low self-esteem? Along with this, do you think that authoritarian parenting style lead to low risk behaviors due to the fact that there was a possible fear response to the negative consequences from parents? Great job!

    Reply
    Olayemi Fadahunsi
    4 May 2021
    12:53pm

    It is very interesting that they did not find a connection to identity status in permissive parents. You would think that because their parents allowed them to completely by themself would be a strong indicator of identity status. And I see that the way the participants rated the parent style of their parents is not equal across all participants, do you think this is a big indicator if a lot of the result is not significant?

    Reply

Share Your Thoughts Cancel Reply

Footer

Department of Psychological Science
University of Mary Washington
Mercer Hall
1301 College Avenue
Fredericksburg, Virginia 22401
540-654-1054
https://cas.umw.edu/psychology/

Privacy:  This website does not collect information about its users other than the name/email shared when leaving comments.

***This site is best viewed using the Chrome or Firefox browsers***

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter

Found an issue with the site?
Contact Dr. Mindy Erchull: merchull@umw.edu

Some aspects of this website don’t work correctly in the Edge browser. We recommend you use Chrome or Firefox to best interact with this site.

×